Sins & Secrets

In 1994, a single bullet wreaked havoc in Lexington, KY. University of Kentucky football player Trent Diguiro was gunned down by a sniper's bullet. For years the case went unsolved, until a former student came forward, and helped identify the killer.

Michelle Theer was an Air Force wife in the military town of Fayetteville until a fatal shooting made her a widow. The investigation into her husband's death led police to the door of an Army Ranger -- taking orders from very unlikely accomplices.

When Tampa bartender Sandee Rozzo was killed, police suspected personal trainer Tracey Humphrey as the culprit. They asked one of Tracey's clients to wear a wire, and discovered he had convinced an unlikely accomplice to pull the trigger.

In 2005, the death of suburban Cleveland resident Rose Marie Essa had doctors and police scratching their heads. An autopsy failed to shed any light on the mystery, but when her physician husband suddenly went missing the shocking truth would be revealed.

On March 23, 2006, a respected horticulturalist is found dead in his Key West home. What appears to be an open-and-shut case proves to be anything but when investigators learn the victim was murdered three days prior by a former tenant and possible lover.

65-year-old Julie Bullard moved to Maine from San Francisco to open the Black Bear Inn in the town of Newry. Years later, the police would discover three mutilated bodies in a woodpile behind her Inn, uncovering this tranquil paradise's dark side.

In 2002, Erika and BJ Sifrit's vacation in Ocean City, MD, ended with them in the back of a squad car arrested for armed robbery. When two dismembered bodies were later unearthed, the connection between the two crimes would reveal a grisly murder.

Chicago’s traditional St. Patrick’s Day celebration was cut short in 2007 when beloved resident Becky Klien suddenly disappeared. The search for the truth quickly morphed into a full-blown murder mystery, complete with sex, drugs and true love gone awry.

A grisly murder in Rome, Georgia, would leave this conservative town reeling. Thad Reynolds, loving husband, father of four and deacon at Hollywood Baptist Church was stabbed 19 times in his office.

In 2007, Anne Stout was a devoted mother living the Rocky Mountain dream until her husband turned up dead in their Missoula home. Only a few scraps of unlikely evidence would reveal the truth about Bill’s murder, as well as his fatal attraction stalker.

As best friends Brian Ognjan and David Tyll arrived in Mio, Michigan, for a hunting trip, the two men had no idea they'd end up as prey. The 18-year investigation that followed would reveal a tale of wrong turns, bullying brothers and a wood chipper.

In June of 2009, the disappearance of a young socialite from an old Charleston family would set the city on edge. When the full story of what happened to 28-year-old Kate Waring was revealed, it would uncover a lesson in naive trust.