الموسم 4・The closer the residents of town get to the answers they seek, the more terrifying their search becomes. Who is the Man in Yellow, and what does he want? Season Four will open doors that some in town will end up wishing had remained closed.

Sa misteryosong pagkawala ni Harold, kinuha nina Troye at Andre si Jonas-ang nawawalang kambal ni Harold at isang drag queen-upang pumalit sa negosyo ng pamilya. Habang itinatago ni Jonas ang kanyang tunay na pagkatao kay Don Manuel, ang mahigpit at homophobic na ama ni Harold, isang lihim ang nagbabantang wasakin ang kanilang pagkakaibigan, pamilya, at kinabukasan.