On Dec. 30, 1999, a fire rips through the Freeman family home in Welch, Oklahoma. Four people are in the house that night, but investigators only find two bodies.

When authorities recover the bodies of Kathy and Danny Freeman, they discover both died from gunshots at close range. Rumors swirl about a police cover-up.

Authorities chase down a shocking lead about a location for possibly finding Lauria Bible and Ashley Freeman's bodies.

After a new sheriff takes over the investigation, the case blows wide open when he discovers a box of evidence that leads to an arrest.