- S1 E1 - The Preacher's DaughtersA small town is shocked when a pastor is charged with the murder of his wife. One of his daughters believes it was suicide. The other is convinced it was cold-blooded murder. After 15 years of silence, the sisters face off.
- S1 E2 - The Case Against KevinKevin was convicted of a heinous crime, killing his mother with his bare hands. But after years in prison, he has cleared his name. Now he wants to confront the family that abandoned him when he needed them most.
- S1 E3 - Jersey JusticeThe chief of police in Bordentown, NJ, is accused of attempted murder. Is this a case of a crooked cop or a miscarriage of justice? His sister has always defended him, but now her faith has been shaken by a blistering accusation.
- S1 E4 - Justice for BritneyTwo young women are found murdered behind a dumpster near Houston, Texas. A highly publicized investigation reveals a suspect among one of the families. Now a cousin in search of answers uncovers the family secrets.
- S1 E5 - Who Killed the Eggman?A man has spent half his life in prison for a murder his brother has publicly confessed to. Now his nephew is trying to free his uncle, but first he has to uncover what really happened.
- S1 E6 - Daughters DividedIn 2013, Kelly Robarge was found viciously beaten to death in the woods near her rural home. One of her daughters suspects their father of the brutal assault. The other believes he's innocent.
- S1 E7 - Father, Mother, NightmareA woman is murdered by her longtime partner, who identifies as female. Now their daughter is faced with an impossible choice: hate her father for his brutal assault or forgive her mother's murderer.
- S1 E8 - A Brother BetrayedA family was living the American dream until their hero was brutally slain. His brother is convinced that another brother is responsible, but his nephew believes those accusations are tearing the family apart.