In May 2016 filmmaker John MacGibbon received a call from Quincy Colleges Plymouth Campus informing him that his motherinlaw Vibeke Rasmussen had not shown up for work After contacting local authorities John and his wife drove from their home in Cambridge Massachusetts to Rasmussens apartment an hour away No one was prepared for the mystery and drama that would follow this event

Still yearning for answers to his motherinlaws fatal disappearance and the tragic aftermath John MacGibbon pores over court documents and interviews murder suspect Tyler Hagmaiers friends and family members Just as we think weve grasped the killers background and family life a new and unexpected twist is revealed What comes next for MacGibbon is headspinning How will he process this

After murder suspect Tyler Hagmaiers body is found floating in the Connecticut River John MacGibbon uncovers more extraordinary information about the young mans past that sheds vital information on MacGibbons motherinlaws sudden disappearance and the discovery of her murdered corpse

While investigating the stabbing death of his motherinlaw John MacGibbon uncovers new evidence long hidden by the police He searches for the final pieces of the puzzle and is met with a letter left behind by the killer whose body had been found drowned not far from the site of the crime With this vital information will MacGibbon be able to rest his search for reasons for this tragic death