The Lying Game

Alec spends time in jail following his arrest for Derek's murder; Rebecca and Sutton make plans for the Mercer family; Mads meets a mysterious new guy.

Sutton lets Emma know that she plans to win back Ethan; Mads visits her father in prison; Dan continues to investigate Derek's murder; Jordan attends his new school.

The twins compete in a tennis match to see which one will live as Sutton; Emma cancels plans with Thayer to tutor Ethan; Laurel brings Mads along on her date with Jordan; new evidence arrives concerning Alec.

Emma suspects that Sutton was not entirely truthful about the night her car went into the lake; Ted invites his family to an event in his honor; Rebecca and Alec play a game of cat and mouse.

Laurel notices a change in Sutton's personality and begins to ask questions; Emma and Thayer continue their investigation; Sutton and Kristin clash during a family dinner.

Emma assumes Sutton's identity in order to trap Rebecca in a lie; Kristin and Alec grow closer.

Sutton begins to lose faith in her mother; Rebecca takes joy in Kristin and Ted's unraveling marriage; Alec sees Jordan as a possible ally in his war with his wife.

Dan and Theresa's wedding does not go as planned; Ethan confronts Emma; Jordan chooses a side in Alec and Rebecca's game; Emma is confused by Sutton's sudden change of heart.

Ethan's confession threatens his relationship with Dan; Sutton gets a mysterious phone call; Emma's feelings for Thayer are put to the test.

The mood at the charity gala turns somber; Dan's ultimatum to Ethan has heartbreaking results; Emma confronts Rebecca about her lost childhood; Ted tries to reveal another secret from his past to Kristin.