One of Us is Lying

Bayview High School deals with the aftermath of Jake's death; a new, mysterious source threatens to expose the Murder Club.[W Network]

Simon Says blackmails the Murder Club with a surprising demand; Janae reveals a huge secret; Jake haunts Addy from beyond the grave; Vanessa holds a rally for Jake.[W Network]

Demands from Simon Says become excruciatingly personal as each member of the Murder Club receives different orders that send them spinning; someone from Jake's past reappears; Janae opens up to Addy.[W Network]

The Murder Club works to find the truth about Giselle; Vanessa digs deeper into Halloween night; another tragedy strikes Bayview.[W Network]

As the rest of Bayview celebrates the holidays, the Murder Club makes a difficult and shocking decision following the news about Giselle, but the police make an unexpected decision of their own.[W Network]

Vanessa doubles down on her investigation into the Murder Club and finds key evidence, making the group worry that she's getting too close to the truth; Evan sees Vanessa in a new light.[W Network]

The Murder Club and Vanessa form an unexpected alliance to uncover the truth about Simon Says; new revelations about Jake's whereabouts over the summer come to light.[W Network]

The Murder Club hatches a risky plan to stop Simon Says once and for all, but there are more pieces to the puzzle than they realize.[W Network]