Ingrid Lyne, a divorced mom of three, went on a date at a baseball game with a man she met online, but the next day, investigators find a chilling crime scene.

Mike Williams mysteriously disappears on his wedding anniversary. It seems like he was eaten by alligators, but a break in the case reveals something else.

When Colorado soccer mom Paige Birgfeld suddenly vanishes, police start to dig for clues and discover that she was living a secret double life.

After Pastor Matthew Winkler is found dead on his bedroom floor, twisted sex fantasies and dark family secrets begin to surface.